I started some pretty vibrant forum posts. Here is a link to some of them. I have also included some quotes I made in the posts. I know it may sound odd because it is out of context, but bare with me. I would like to include some of my writing in this forum.
"I personally only recommend Rush albums from 1976 until 1982. Then newer stuff sounds a bit dry to me, and Getty can't really hit the notes anymore. I guess the same thing happened to Robert Plant."
"Yes, many people forget that Queen and Led Zepplin are basically prog."
"You are telling me that "Stairway to heaven" and "Bohemian Rhapsody" aren't basic prog song structures?" Some guy disagrees with me.
"Well, my viewpoint is that the Prog's roots come from Jazz, folk and Classical mixed together, so I would think that "prog" as a genre of music is one of the most open-minded (for a lack of a better phrase) out there."
"Well, the difference is that Led Zepplin and Queen have that blues thing going, whereas Yes and Genesis are more English Folk Rock, but their prog sensibilities come from the same place."
"Good points. I have to admit that prog stagnated after the 1970's, however Marillan is one exception of a bright spot in the eighties. And Radiohead is a bright spot for the nineties."
But what was that "preformed on ice" period Rick Wakeman went through after Yes. That was so cheesy. A low point for prog. Rick was a bit too full of himself. And Emerson too. These guys really damaged prog's reputation.
Here is a link.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AXlZ0x0Ghrk&feature =related
Pure mid evil cheese.....
I would never have known that this topic I started would be so heated. After reading all the posts, I now remember one other point I wanted to make. One guy mentioned this in this topic too. Why has modern prog morphed into metal/thrash territory (ie, Dream Theater).
What ever happened to Fuzz guitars(ie Steve Hackett, early genesis), 12 sting guitars (again, Genesis-esque), buzzy imperfect mellotrons, and frantic jazz-esque solos like Steve Howe.
All I have to say to modern prog acts is, go easy on the generic metal distortion sounds. If I want to hear that, I would just listen to early Metallica.
PS, that first Genesis album isn't all that bad. There are some nice melodies there. Nothing on that album is as bad as Invisible Touch yah!
"I agree with you. It is a bit silly that the whole world has decided on the word "prog" rock. Symphonic rock and Art rock are good terms, but I guess the general public got confused.
So whether we like it or not, the term "prog" is here to stay because people always have the need to label things, and I guess I can live with that. The good thing is that when I say "Prog" at least people know exactly the era and bands I am refering to."
Who is your favourite Keyboard player from the 1970's?
This was a hot topic. Seems everybody has an opinion.
"Mine would have to be Tony Banks. How about you?"
"ELP had some bright spots in the early days, but latter they got so boring. Rick Wright is a good choice. He is very under ratted."
"Roger Hodgson."
Is he the guy from Supertramp? If so, they are good."Gentle giant had great potential. I am trying to remember that really melodic slow song they had, I can't remember the title. I loved that song.
Oh, here it is...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mN6ZK1TvtBI
Think of me with kindness"
Do all guitar Synths suck?
One guy recommends I take a look at "axon".
<object width="425" height="344">
<param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/UMugCUNW-9o&hl=en&fs=1" />
<param name="allowFullScreen" value="true" /><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/UMugCUNW-9o&hl=en&fs=1" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowfullscreen="true" height="344" width="425"></object>
Is Korean built better than Chinese for guitars?
Best bass player ever, and best looking bass?
I will be unoriginal here and say Chris Squire. Duhhh. And another point. I think the 4001 is the best looking bass ever. Looks matter too.
Best Synth solo ever?!?
I am not sure, but I think it was Heart. They had a song called Magic man. I think that is the one with the killer synth solo.
No comments:
Post a Comment